Travel down to the most southern point in the contiguous 48 states with this fantastic fare from American Airlines. Flights from New York-LaGuardia to Key West Florida are available for just $163 roundtrip for travel this September and into October.

Travel Availability

Tickets at this price are available on select travel days starting in early September through October 1, with returns possible through the end of October. Most departures are valid on Sunday through Wednesdays, with return flights from MIA on Tuesdays through Fridays. Other days of the week may be available.

On some itineraries a long layover in Miami might be required on the return segment but if you are flexible with travel dates they can be avoided.

As an example, I found seats available departing New York LGA on Tuesday, September 24, and returning from Key West EYW on Thursday, October 3, 2019, with quick connections on both legs of the journey.


This Basic Economy fare includes a carry-on bag plus one personal item. A checked bag costs $30 each way.

Seat Assignments

Seats will be assigned at random upon check-in for this price.

Alternate Fares

American's Main Cabin Economy fare is $223 roundtrip, which includes advanced seat assignments and allows ticket changes/upgrades for a fee. A checked bag will still cost the same $30 each way.

Related: Which South Florida Airport is Best? MIA, FLL, or PBI

See our fare details for booking info.

For more sale fares to South Florida, have a look at all of our fares to Miami (MIA), Ft. Lauderdale (FLL), and West Palm Beach (PBI) flight deals pages.

Need a room in Key West? Here's what's available for the mentioned dates on Hotelwatchdog.

All products and services mentioned on Airfarewatchdog are independently selected by our team of expert travelers. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

More Stories You'll Love