It's fairly easy to find this price for travel on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays, from late August through April, excluding peak holiday travel.
Searching Orbitz, I found seats departing New York JFK on Thursday, August 29, returning from Maui OGG on Thursday, September 5. Perfect for a week-long trip to Hawaii over Labor Day weekend.
This price includes a carry-on bag plus one small personal item. A checked bag costs $30 each way.
These are regular economy fares and include advanced seat assignments.
The same fare is available from New York-Laguardia (LGA) on American and United. United's Basic Economy fare only includes a small personal item, but it does have more availability in early August.
See our fare details for booking info.
Need a room in Maui? Here's what's available for the mentioned dates on Hotelwatchdog.