Fly nonstop from New York to Reykjavik for $169 round-trip on WOW Air for travel on a few dates this spring or fall.
For example, we found seats departing New York JFK on Thursday, September 27, returning from Reykjavik KEF on Friday, October 5. A few other dates are available for travel in late May/June and September/October.
This is part of WOW Air's flash sale from yesterday, which has $69 one-way fares on all routes from the US to Iceland. Seats are more scarce today, but some of these fares are still sticking around if you are flexible with travel dates.
This price only includes one small personal item (small backpack, large purse, etc.) up to 22 lbs. You can add a larger carry-on bag for $40 each way or a checked bag for $50 each way. At $210-$230 round-trip with sufficient baggage included, this is still an excellent price to cross the Atlantic.
Need a room in Reykjavik? Here's what's available for the above dates on Hotelwatchdog.