Fly nonstop from New York to Milan for $499 round-trip on Emirates.
Searching Emirates, we found seats for travel over December/January holidays, departing JFK on December 26, returning from MXP on January 5.
Other dates are also available from November through May. Fares may vary by a few bucks ($496 to $499) depending on travel dates.
See our New York JFK fare listings for a complete look at current finds.
Need a room in Milan? Here's what's available for the above dates on Hotelwatchdog.