Fly nonstop from New York to Reykjavik for $694 round-trip on Delta.
Searching Delta.com, we found seats for peak summer travel, departing JFK on Tuesday, July 21, returning from KEF on Wednesday, July 29.
Other dates are also available for travel in July/August.
For booking info, see our Fare Details.
Need a room in Reykjavik? Here's a look at what's available for the above dates on Hotelwatchdog.