Airfarewatchdog
Welcome!
  • Real deals from your departure city
  • Verified by our Dealhounds

Pardon me, this seat taken?

Travel Q&A

You can submit your own question to us at askgeorge@airfarewatchdog.com. We will try to answer as many as possible. If we use your question in a future newsletter, we will send you a free Airfarewatchdog T-shirt. We do not print your name or other details in our newsletters.

To post a comment to one of our Q&A's please click on "read more" and then "post a comment."

Current posts | Categories

Pardon me, this seat taken?

Q. My partner and I have used up our Frequent Flyer miles on upgrades to first class, and are looking for an alternative way to buy more space on a Philadephia/Los Angeles round-trip. Our solution would be to purchase three adjacent coach seats which would give the two of us enough room to stretch out. Since we will purchase two of the seats with credit card points, our additional cash outlay would be for the one round-trip coach seat. Much cheaper than two first class upgrades!

How do the airlines feel about this? If any of the flights were full, would they try and put someone in our empty seat? Can I get the airline to award me the FF points for both seats? What are our risks for trying this approach?

A. We've definitely heard of others doing this as well. And yes, a flight attendant did attempt to fill the empty seat so that another couple on board could sit together. Of course, the passenger who purchased both seats had to speak up and say so, which kind of left him looking curmudgeony and Scroogey in the eyes of the crew and fellow passengers. Wait, did that happen, or are we remembering an episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm? Hmm...not sure. However, the point is, if you pay for two seats, you get two seats, they're yours, miles and all, end of story.

The only risks we can imagine is if one of your booked seats were to be bumped (which does happen from time to time), or the above mentioned awkward Larry David-ish scenario. We'd suggest checking with a reservationist at your airline for a less full flight, just to avoid any kerfuffles.


Post a Comment


(Please do not use your real name - this screen name will be your public identity on Airfarewatchdog.com)
(Your email address will not display in post)



It's not selfish to take an extra seat. Airlines sell seats on planes by demand, and if there is a much greater demand for seats, they may replace the aircraft with a bigger one, just as they cancel flights, and switch to smaller ones if the demand is less. Having paid for two seats for yourself, tho, I wouldn't assume that I'd get FF miles for both of them. I would definitely ask the airline, not a website, because their word doesn't have the force of an employee. If you get a "yes" to the question, be sure to note the date, time and name of the customer service person who gave it to you.
by mickisue on Wednesday, May 12, 2010
There are some non-selfish reasons for needing that extra seat, namely medical. My husband had to make a business flight shortly after having knee surgery. Getting that extra seat would have allowed him room to stretch and elevate his leg. He suffered pain from the drinks carts being smashed into him all through the flight, and the experience set back his recovery.
by Redawuk on Wednesday, May 12, 2010
I recently took an Air New Zealand flight from LA to London. I took advantage of an option they offer when I checked in at LAX - they call it twin seats. For an extra $60 I purchased the middle seat next to my aisle seat. Problem was, on the way home, there were no middle seats available for a twin purchase. It was indeed nice on the 10 plus hours outbound.
by fruitland on Wednesday, May 12, 2010
The other problem could be the airlines nasty habit as of late to re-assign your seat numbers, and not necessarily keep all the people in a party together. You could find your 3 seats in different rows. I suggest monitoring the reservation carefully. Especially if you're flying Delta, as they seem to do this on a weekly basis.
by sayhello on Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Some of you don't seem to understand that when a person travelling with you does not show up for the flight that ticket is cancelled and the seat is put back into inventory even though your husband or whoever paid for the seat. What you should do in that case is cancel the reservation before the flight and use whatever credit is left for a flight some other time. Most fare rules state that a "no-show" for a flight means automatic cancellation without a refund, etc. You agree to the fare rules when you book a ticket. If you buy two seats for YOURSELF, that's another story.
by ralphsdad on Friday, June 05, 2009
I think you should just suck it up. It is selfish to be buying up seats while other people that need to book that flight, can't get a seat because someone wants to 'stretch out'. Others have just as valid a reason to get to a destination as you do. Why do people think it is all about them with no regard to others.
by snugs on Friday, May 15, 2009
I am the OP for this question, and I also emailed USAirways (which we will be using) with a version of the question and they responded that I should name the third booking with the word "extra" and my last name, ie "Extra Smith." I will try to associate my FF# with the seat for mileage credit, but am not sure if that will work.
by on Saturday, May 02, 2009
I think Spirit is the worst offender here.....I also had bought (at a very stiff price I might add) emergency row seating for my husband and myself, and our two adult children. Last minute, my husband had something come up with work and was unable to go. When assigning the seats, I had put his name on the window seat. When he did not board, they turned around and gave his seat away FREE to someone else. I had my adult kids (both husky) in the row of three, so they could stretch out, and myself on the end across the isle from them. The guy that the airline gave my husbands paid seat to, ended up with the window seat, and my kids both squished. I traded my son who was pushed into the middle, so they could each have an isle seat......but I was not happy with the airline at all. This same scenario played out from Detroit to NY, then again to FL......then again in reverse. Talk about a ticked off flyer! 6 times! Not only was my husbands ticket paid for, but I had also paid extra for the emergency row seat that was given away to someone for free! I sure don't see myself ever flying with them again!
by trpetersons on Saturday, May 02, 2009
Sometimes, if a couple buys a window seat and an aisle , nobody will buy the middle seat. If they do, they most certainly would switch to either the aisle or window so you can be together. Won't work on full flights, but it's worth the try!
by Fitz on Friday, May 01, 2009
When I worked for AA and DL, we had customers buy an extra seat from time to time, for their musical instrument or for their comfort. The name on the tkt said Smith, Trombone, or Smith, 2nd Seat. We honored their extra seat (and even defended it if necessary). If we had to ask for volunteers in a "bumping" situation due to overbooking, we paid the passenger for the extra seat if he/she was willing to give it up.
by Lowicklady on Friday, May 01, 2009
I've booked an extra seat on three or four flights over the last two years and the reservation is for "Smith, Extra Seat" or "Smith, 2nd Seat" and I've not had any problems -- other than United/Lufthansa telling me that I'd booked the extra seat for a flight three weeks prior to my flight. They resolved the issue and we had the only empty seat on the plane between me and my mom on an international flight. I highly recommend an extra seat on international flights if the fares are good.
by SandyBee on Friday, May 01, 2009
Spirit put someone in our empty seat! I purchased 3 round trip tickets to Tampa from Atlantic City. One of us couldn't go but it was cheaper just to tell them at the gate on the departure day that the individual couldn't make it last minute than paying the cancellation fee to another date. We did get a good discount since we belong to the $9 Club. But I made a point to the attendant that I paid for 3 seats and I'm traveling with a 5 year old and would like all 3 seats. She said it should be all right. Well, I get into the row of 3 seats and there's a person in the middle. They put someone in that seat that was reserved for the ticket I purchased. The poor guy saw that my grandson and I would be separated and he volunteered to move over to the aisle seat. Maybe it's best if you don't tell them at all that the individual won't be flying. Let them figure it out.

by JDH on Friday, May 01, 2009
I was wondering the same thing. How does one justify buying several tickets for same flight in his/her own name??? Claim passenger over-size? which would be seen not to be true on boarding..... hmmmm... ok, what is the answer to this???
by RGValleyGal on Friday, May 01, 2009
Been there, done that. What a pain in the a$$! I always bought my son a ticket even when he was a baby. I brought my car seat on board & strapped him in. I had flight attendents try to check my car seat & give up the seat even AFTER I proved I had paid for the seat.

I also have problems because my husband & son are named the same. The airlines software only looks at first & names, not Sr & Jr. They take my $ for 3 seats but try to only give me 2 boarding passes and 2 seats on the airplane. I have to print out the tickets to get some 20 character unique id to prove they each get a seat.

by GrandeMocha on Friday, May 01, 2009
What I don't understand is the security issue of having the name of the passenger who is flying on a specific ticket. Wouldn't there be a problem if the same name appears on two tickets on the same flight?
by pen4hire on Friday, May 01, 2009
Advertisement
© 1998-2012 Smarter Travel Media LLC. All Rights Reserved Privacy Statement | Terms of Use
Advertisement
http://rd.airfarewatchdog.com/?ad_user_tracking=%5Bsource%3D%2Ctaparam%3D%2Csupmt%3D%5D