The next airline regulation we need: You pay for a whole seat, you get a whole seat
by George HobicaAirfarewatchdog.com
by George Hobica
Now that the Federally-mandated 3-hour tarmac delay rule is in place, and hasn’t brought down the airline industry, maybe Secretary of Transportation Ray LaHood needs to have his Department of Transportation address a far more common aviation crisis: the growing number of people who are too fat to fit into tiny airplane seats and the discomfort they cause their seat mates.
Without a doubt, Marsha St. Clair, a Los Angeles-based retiree, would agree. St. Clair flew recently with her busband and sat next to a woman who was so obese that she “spilled over” into a third of St. Clair’s middle seat on a Boeing 757, forcing her to remain in full body contact for the duration of the 5-hour flight. “I paid for an entire seat, but only got less than two thirds of it,” she says. “Please tell me that there is an FAA regulation regarding this situation.”
Well, Marsha, there isn’t. But there should be.
Although some airlines have rules addressing such situations, including Southwest, which requires “customers of size” to purchase a second seat, there’s no standardized regulation.
But with figures from the National Center for Health Statistics stating that more than one-third of adults are obese, and that another third are merely “overweight,” something needs to be done.
Now I realize that some people will say that obesity is a genetic condition or a handicap, and it may well be, although the fact that the ranks of the obese in the U.S. grow year after year suggests that it’s not (DNA doesn’t mutate quite that quickly).
But let’s for the sake of argument say that obesity is a handicap, something beyond the individual’s control.
In that case, it should be treated just like any other physical challenge. What can be done? Well one solution would be for the D.O.T. and other nations’ transportation authorities to mandate that all airlines install extra wide “obesity” seats in their economy class sections. Each plane could have, say, one or two rows with two by two seating instead of the usual three by three configuration. Obese passengers could be pre-assigned these seats, either for the usual economy fare, or perhaps by paying a small premium. These seats wouldn't enjoy any other special services or extra legroom, just extra width.
If no obese passengers are flying on a particular flight, normally sized passengers could upgrade at the last minute to these more comfortable seats, by paying a premium, or get them by luck of the drawer if there are no takers. Airlines such as jetBlue already charge more for extra leg room, but I’ll bet what a lot of passengers really want is more room for their posteriors.
Barring that solution, or in addition to it, the D.O.T. should require all airlines to publish clear policies stating how they will protect squished and uncomfortable passengers such as St. Clair, who find themselves getting less than what they paid for. It’s only fair.
- November, 2014 (117)
- October, 2014 (117)
- September, 2014 (119)
- August, 2014 (109)
- July, 2014 (116)
- June, 2014 (105)
- May, 2014 (90)
- April, 2014 (93)
- March, 2014 (74)
- February, 2014 (55)
- January, 2014 (63)
- December, 2013 (41)
- November, 2013 (53)
- October, 2013 (66)
- September, 2013 (26)
- August, 2013 (27)
- July, 2013 (32)
- June, 2013 (28)
- May, 2013 (30)
- April, 2013 (29)
- March, 2013 (32)
- February, 2013 (29)